Xylie's American Idol Review

Here is A Review of Last Night's American Idol from y four-year old critic:

Brooke - Simon is way wrong. She is beautiful and good and my favorite! (mommy agrees)

David Cook - I don't know if I like his song or not, it's just off (mommy agrees)

Ramielle- I really like her. She sings pretty and looks pretty and it's good to be little sometimes (Mommy sighs)

Jason Castro - I'm not really sure that is the song for him. I don't think I like him, but let's see what they have to say I think they will make him sad and that isn't nice. (Mommy sort of agrees)

Carly - Hmmm, she just seems a little bit nervous (Mommy says hmmm?)

David Archuletta - Wow, he is a beautiful singer! Wow!(Mommy agrees)

Kristy - hmmm, pretty good (I was surprised Xylie usually loves her) (Mommy thought Krisy did fine but would have liked it more without the band)

Seyesha - I want to like her but it was a little too roughish (Mommy doesn't quite understand)

Michael - I just don't know about him. His voice is too scratchy and I don't like that thing around his neck. Naw, he just doesn't have it. (Despite mommy pleading with her to change her mind)